
Repair when
- One part has failed: a station, the amplifier, the strike, a panel button.
- The rest of the system has been reliable.
- Parts are available.
- The building is happy with what the system does.
Replace when
- Different parts keep failing. Three or more repairs on different components in a year is a pattern.
- Parts are no longer made and no compatible substitute exists.
- The wiring is failing in several places.
- The building wants video, phone answering or delivery codes.
A rule of thumb
Add up what you've spent on repairs in the last two years and what the current repair would cost. If that is approaching half the price of a replacement, get a replacement quote. If it's a small fraction, repair. Connextivity, another New York integrator, uses a similar threshold: repair below about 30% of replacement cost, replace above about 50%.
Questions to ask a company that recommends replacement
- What exactly has failed?
- Can that part be replaced on its own? If not, why not?
- Can the existing wiring be reused?
- What would a repair cost, for comparison?
A company that can't answer the first question hasn't diagnosed the system.
The middle option
Replacing only the entry panel, or upgrading on the existing wire, often gives most of the benefit of a new system at a fraction of the cost. See replacement and upgrades.
Common questions
My intercom is 30 years old. Should I replace it?
Age alone isn't a reason. Many 30-year-old systems still work well with occasional parts. Replace when it keeps failing or can't do what the building needs.
